A £6 MILLION plan to improve safety on the A38 between Liskeard and Trerulefoot has been branded “half-baked” by a road safety campaign group.

Safe38 chairman James Millidge has called on National Highways to scrap the proposals and develop what he describes as “an appropriate long-term solution”.

His warning comes as a public consultation on the proposed Liskeard to Trerulefoot Safety Scheme gets under way, with hundreds of people attending a consultation event in Liskeard on Monday.

National Highways says it will listen to the concerns raised by local people and use the feedback to help shape the proposals.

The scheme, estimated to cost between £5m and £6m, is expected to enter detailed design in 2027/28, with work targeted for late 2028/29, subject to funding and no delays.

National Highways head of safety for the South West, Jack Mason, said: “We’re still in the early stages at the moment.

“We’ll take all that feedback away, analyse it and look at where we need to work on the scheme to get the right outcome.”

However, Safe38 says the proposals fail to tackle one of the biggest safety issues on the route – central reservation gaps and right-turn movements.

Collision figures for the Menheniot junction between 2012 and 2024 record one fatal collision, three serious injuries and nine slight injuries.

National Highways has compared the figures with the notorious A30 junction at Plusha, near Launceston, where there were three fatal, seven serious and 10 slight injury collisions over the same period.

Mr Millidge has written to South East Cornwall MP Anna Gelderd outlining the group’s concerns.

“We are also concerned the scheme does not address what we believe to be one of the fundamental requirements for this section of the A38: the closure of the central reservation gaps,” he said.

“We are particularly concerned about the proposed removal of some of the right-turn movements, especially at Menheniot.

“There appears to be widespread agreement that, ultimately, what is required is a grade-separated junction together with appropriate provision for local access.”

Safe38 says this would allow the majority of central reservation gaps and right turns between Liskeard and Trerulefoot to be closed while maintaining access for communities and businesses.

However, the current scheme provides neither a grade-separated junction nor a dedicated local access road.

National Highways says grade-separated options are not currently viable because of funding constraints and are not considered value for money, although they could be introduced in the future.

Mr Mason said the scale of the safety problem meant action was needed now.

“The road as a whole performs about 34 per cent worse than the national average, but it’s these right-turn collisions in particular that we’re really concerned about,” he said.

“There have been four fatal collisions involving right turns in the last 20 years, and we expect that to continue if we don’t do something about it.”

Safe38 fears removing existing turning movements without equivalent alternative routes could create new problems.

“We are concerned this could have significant and currently difficult-to-quantify consequences for the local road network and for businesses that rely upon existing access arrangements,” said Mr Millidge.

He warned of “increased traffic on unsuitable local roads, including rat-running”, as well as potentially dangerous U-turns on the A38 when drivers are unable to make previously available movements.

Mr Mason said National Highways had worked closely with Cornwall Council to assess the potential impact on local roads.

“We’ve worked really closely with Cornwall Council for a long time to make sure we’ve assessed those roads properly,” he said.

“We’ve undertaken traffic surveys and looked at which roads can take a little bit more traffic. In the grand scheme of things, the turning movements aren’t significant compared with the A38, so it’s not a lot of vehicles moving.

“We’ve recognised that we can’t close every junction just because it’s on the A38. We’ve had to make a balance between which junctions can and can’t be closed.

“We’re not pushing the problem elsewhere.”

Safe38 has also highlighted access to Adrenalin Quarry and Menheniot railway station, warning the scheme could weaken links between communities north and south of the A38.

“Whilst Safe38 welcomes investment in road safety, we believe any safety scheme must improve road safety without having an adverse impact on the safety, security and livelihoods of the communities and businesses along the route,” said Mr Millidge.

Mr Mason acknowledged suggestions from local people for a flyover or bridge to maintain access, but said the cost remained a major barrier.

“It’s not a question of us not wanting to put in solutions such as a flyover,” he said.

“These kinds of solutions are very, very expensive, and it’s a case of having the funding available to deliver them.

“In the meantime, we’re saying we need to do something now to avoid those fatal and serious injury collisions in the future.”

An average-speed camera scheme remains under consideration, depending on the junction improvements eventually delivered.

Mr Mason said the scheme could be delivered in around three years if funding is secured.

“I’m expecting it to be around about three years, although obviously that is subject to funding,” he said.

The consultation will help shape the proposals ahead of detailed design work.